Auburn Women Killed in Tragic Crash, Sparking Community Grief and Safety Concerns
The city of Auburn, Maine, is enveloped in grief following the tragic deaths of Catherine Chafin, 57, and Emily Bennett, 44, two beloved members of the John F. Murphy Homes community, in a devastating car crash on the evening of May 14, 2025. The collision, which occurred at the intersection of Washington Street and Beech Hill Road, has left the tight-knit community reeling, prompting an outpouring of sorrow and renewed calls for action to address longstanding safety concerns at the site. As families, friends, and neighbors mourn, the incident has sparked a broader conversation about protecting vulnerable populations and ensuring safer roads for all.
The accident unfolded around 6:55 p.m. when a 2016 Honda Odyssey van, operated by John F. Murphy Homes, attempted to cross Washington Street from Beech Hill Road. The van, carrying Chafin, Bennett, and two staff members, was struck by a southbound 2017 Chevrolet Silverado pickup truck driven by Jason Plummer, a 50-year-old from Salisbury, Massachusetts. The impact was catastrophic, resulting in severe injuries and extensive damage to both vehicles. Chafin was rushed to Central Maine Medical Center in Lewiston but was pronounced dead shortly after arrival. Bennett, also critically injured, succumbed to her injuries early the following morning. The two staff members, aged 21 and 19, sustained non-life-threatening injuries and were treated at the same hospital. Plummer, the pickup truck driver, escaped serious physical harm but is undoubtedly affected by the emotional weight of the tragedy.
Catherine Chafin and Emily Bennett were cherished residents of John F. Murphy Homes, a respected nonprofit dedicated to supporting individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities, as well as autism spectrum disorder. The organization provides not only housing and care but also opportunities for personal growth and community engagement. Todd Goodwin, the CEO, described the women as “delightful” and deeply loved, noting their significant impact on both the organization and the broader Auburn community. One of the women worked part-time at the nonprofit’s central office, a testament to their commitment and capability. Friends and staff remember Chafin and Bennett for their warmth, kindness, and ability to brighten any room. Their deaths have left a profound void, particularly as they were returning from a routine bingo game, an activity meant to foster joy and connection.
The intersection where the crash occurred has long been a concern for Auburn residents. Data from the Maine Department of Transportation indicates that 14 crashes were reported at Washington Street and Beech Hill Road in 2024, resulting in 10 injuries. The addition of two fatalities has intensified demands for immediate safety improvements. James Arel, a local resident who has lived near the intersection for 26 years, expressed frustration with the current setup, particularly the flashing red light at Beech Hill Road, which he believes is insufficient to manage the high volume and speed of traffic. Many in the community echo Arel’s sentiment, advocating for a full traffic signal to prevent further tragedies.
The Auburn Police Department, with assistance from Lewiston police, is conducting a thorough investigation to determine the precise cause of the crash. Authorities are examining factors such as speed, visibility, road conditions, and potential mechanical issues, though no conclusions have been released. The complexity of the incident, involving multiple vehicles and individuals, necessitates detailed forensic analysis, including accident reconstruction to analyze impact points and vehicle data. The police have urged witnesses to come forward with any information that could aid the investigation.
For John F. Murphy Homes, the loss is particularly devastating. The organization is not only grieving the deaths of two residents but also supporting its injured staff members and the broader community of clients and employees. Goodwin emphasized the emotional toll, describing a state of shock and sorrow among staff and residents. The nonprofit is undertaking an internal review to assess the circumstances of the crash and strengthen safety protocols, particularly around transportation, which is a critical service for its clients. This tragedy underscores the immense responsibility of organizations caring for vulnerable populations, where even routine outings carry inherent risks.
The Auburn community is rallying to honor Chafin and Bennett, with plans for memorial services in the works to celebrate their lives and provide a space for collective mourning. Local organizations, churches, and advocacy groups are offering support to affected families and pushing for systemic changes to prevent similar incidents. The crash has also highlighted the vulnerability of individuals with developmental disabilities, who rely on caregivers and systems designed to protect them. Ensuring their safety requires rigorous training, well-maintained vehicles, and careful route planning, alongside collaboration with local authorities to address infrastructure challenges.
As Auburn grapples with this heartbreak, the deaths of Catherine Chafin and Emily Bennett are a stark reminder of the fragility of life and the urgent need for action. Their legacy, marked by compassion and resilience, lives on in the hearts of those who knew them and in the community’s resolve to seek justice and safety. The hope is that their loss will catalyze meaningful change, from enhanced traffic controls at dangerous intersections to strengthened protections for those who depend on others for care. In their memory, Auburn is called to reflect, heal, and commit to a future where such tragedies are prevented.
